Open Access Article
Law and Social Justice. 2024; 1: (1) ; 9-12 ; DOI: 10.12208/j.lsj.20240003.
Analysis of “Same Crime of Buying and Selling” in the Crime of Human Abduction and Trafficking
拐卖人口罪中“买、卖同罪”探析
作者：
Weinan Hu *
大连海洋大学 辽宁大连
*通讯作者：
Weinan Hu,单位：大连海洋大学 辽宁大连；
发布时间: 2024-11-19 总浏览量: 222
PDF 全文下载
引用本文
摘要
本文首先探讨了我国人口贩卖犯罪中“买卖同罪”的不足，包括买受人刑事责任相对较轻、法定刑单一、从轻处罚适用条件不明确等问题。文章第二部分回顾了在人口贩卖犯罪中对“买卖同罪”的认识。罗翔教授、Ken Sangmoto教授主要主张“买卖同罪”的观念，而车浩教授、白浪涛教授则持反对态度，并在本文中对其反对“买卖同罪”的立场进行了进一步阐述和论证。此外，从“买卖同罪”的争议角度，提出了加强我国人口贩卖犯罪处理的建议，这些建议主要集中在加强买受人的处罚、细化法定刑规定、明确从轻处罚的适用标准等方面。
关键词： 买和买一样的罪；有利位置；完美建议
Abstract
This article first discusses the shortcomings of the crime of human trafficking in China, which involve "different crimes of buying and selling." These include the relatively light criminal responsibility of the buyer, the singular statutory punishment, and the unclear conditions for applying a lighter punishment. The second part of the article reviews the perspectives on the "same crime of buying and selling" in the context of human trafficking. Professors Luo Xiang and Ken Sangmoto primarily advocate for the concept of the "same crime of buying and selling," while Professors Che Hao and Bai Langtao oppose this viewpoint. They further elaborate on and provide reasons for their stance against the "same crime of buying and selling" in this article. Additionally, suggestions for enhancing the handling of human trafficking crimes in China are presented from the perspective of the controversy surrounding the "same crime of buying and selling." These suggestions mainly focus on strengthening penalties for buyers, refining statutory criminal regulations, and specifying criteria for applying lenient punishments.
Key words： Buy the Same Crime as Buy; Vantage Point; Perfect Suggestion
参考文献 References
[1] Bai Langtao. Does the crime of bribery require an increase in the statutory penalty? [EB/OL]. https://mp.weixin.qq. com/s/c24G5_OjiFA_FEtL6yRbA,2022-02-09/2022-02-22.
[2] Che Hao. Should the Penalty be Increased for the Crime of Buying Trafficked Women? [EB/OL]. https://mp.weixin.qq. com/s/z3H85NwArPdREokiVur6Ew,2022-02-07/2022-02-22.
[3] Liang Fan. On the Crime of Buying Women and Children and Its Legislative Improvement [D]. Jilin: Yanbian University, 2020.
[4] Luo Xiang. Why do I still advocate increasing the penalty for bribing women and children? [EB/OL]. https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/UUwTBaeSCU5Rw_fSKNSZMw, 2022-02-07/2022-02-21.
[5] Mou Xueyan. On the crime of buying abducted women and children [D]. Henan: Zhengzhou University, 2018.
[6] Sang Benqian. Why is it necessary to legislate to severely punish the crime of bribing abducted and trafficked women? [EB/OL].https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/qgAdL1XJTpf0OgtX3yD9Gg,2022-02-08/2022-02-21.
[7] Wang Jichun, Xu Ziqian. Striving for a balance between severity-On the improvement of the crime of buying abducted and trafficked women [J]. Journal of Taiyuan Normal University (Social Science Edition), 2018, 17(1): 62.
引用本文
WeinanHu, 拐卖人口罪中“买、卖同罪”探析[J]. 法学与社会正义, 2024; 1: (1) : 9-12.